Every year, a few books get new life thanks to their movie adaptations. And every time the next book is adapted to the big screen, we witness a heated discussion about what is better: the book or its adaptation.
We should not compare these two worlds. They are governed by different rules and aimed at reaching different goals. Many of the quotes presented below prove the comparison is pointless and leads nowhere.
Comparing a book to a movie is like comparing glasses to a mirror. The same ingredient doesn’t make them similar.
On the other hand, it’s good to keep in mind all the advantages of a book adaptation. The movie restores interest in the book and its author. It can increase or create an awareness of the book, making many people reach for it for the first time. It helps discover new meanings and a new context.
The more people talk, the better. For the movie or the book. Obviously, it doesn’t apply to a bad movie adaptation (a bad movie or a missed adaptation), or a bad book.
One of the best book-vs-movie quotes comes from J.W. Eagan (by the way, do you know who this person is?). “Never judge a book by its movie” is brilliant, because it encourages to form two different opinions: one about the book and the other about the movie.
Is this list missing a quote? Share your suggestions in the comments below.
Read also 50 most inspirational quotes from books
Books vs. movies – 25 best quotes
Books and movies are like apples and oranges. They both are fruit, but taste completely different.
Having your book turned into a movie is like seeing your oxen turned into bouillon cubes.
–John le Carre
Artists use frauds to make human beings seem more wonderful than they really are. Dancers show us human beings who move much more gracefully than human beings really move. Films and books and plays show us people talking much more entertainingly than people really talk, make paltry human enterprises seem important. Singers and musicians show us human beings making sounds far more lovely than human beings really make. Architects give us temples in which something marvelous is obviously going on. Actually, practically nothing is going on
I’m all for whatever transitions the book properly to a movie.
I’m not from the movie world. I’m from the book world.
If you truly love film, I think the healthiest thing to do is not read books on the subject. I prefer the glossy film magazines with their big color photos and gossip columns, or the National Enquirer. Such vulgarity is healthy and safe.
There are things in the book you could never do in a movie.
The summer movies are coming out. My advice: just stay home and burn a good book.
I have three kids who like Harry Potter so I was sort of aware of it. You can’t really move from it: it’s on buses, in stores, it’s everywhere. One of my kids has read the books; the other two are too small but they like the movies.
I wanted to write and direct movies and not be forced to adapt them from a bestselling book.
–Francis Ford Coppola
What makes a good book and what makes a good movie are totally different things.
I enjoy about 1 out of 100 movies, it’s about the same proportion to books published that I care to read.
I love the movies, and when I go to see a movie that’s been made from one of my books, I know that it isn’t going to be exactly like my novel because a lot of other people have interpreted it. But I also know it has an idea that I’ll like because that idea occurred to me, and I spent a year, or a year and a half of my life working on it.
As an author, you can’t expect a movie to be an illustration of the book. If that’s what you hope for, you shouldn’t sell the rights.
I’ve had nine of my books adapted to film, and almost all were enjoyable. I’ve been very lucky with Hollywood, and look forward to more movies being adapted. But I don’t get involved in that process. I know nothing about making movies and I stay away from it and hope for the best.
When you’re making a movie of a book, people are always waiting with their knives.
I couldn’t be happier about being a part of ‘Hunger Games’ and to play Katniss. I have a huge responsibility to the fans of this incredible book and I don’t take it lightly. I will give everything I have to these movies and to this role to make it worthy of Suzanne Collins’ masterpiece.
The book is a film that takes place in the mind of the reader. That’s why we go to movies and say, “Oh, the book is better.”
We want a book to be a book. We’ll have all the interactive bells and whistles but our intent is to engage young people in reading, not to show them a movie.
Movies are not scripts – movies are films; they’re not books, they’re not the theatre.
I’m obsessed with zombies. I like watching zombie movies and I read zombie books.
OK, publishing a book and releasing a movie is all very well, but Tottenham beating Man. U. 3-2… priceless.
I really believe that the movie will never be as good as the book, both because the book goes on longer – a movie is basically an abridgment of a book – and because books are internal. But they are incredibly powerful. The visual format is, you know, amazing.
It’s such a complicated thing to put a movie together. The book world is so much simpler.
I’m always frustrated when somebody makes a movie out of a book and they leave the book behind, or the heart of it.
Books vs. movies – infographic
Feel free to share this quotegraphic on your blog or in social media.
• • •
Never stop exploring. Here are other lists to check out: